- I Am Free (Who the Son Sets Free)
- I Am Your Beloved
- I Can Only Imagine
- I Could Sing Of Your Love Forever
- I Exhalt Thee
- I Give You My Heart
- I Have Decided To Follow Jesus
- I Lean Not On My Own UnderstandingAlt
- I Love You Lord
- I Love Your Presence
- I Speak Jesus
- I Want To Be Where You Are
- I Will Rise
- I Will Wait For You (Psalm 130)
- I Worship You
- I'll Fly Away
- I'm Listening
- If You Want Me To
- In Christ Alone (My Hope Is Found)
- In Over My Head (Crash Over Me)
- Is He Worthy
- It Came Upon The Midnight Clear